A Quick Book Review: Dreaming the Beatles


So first up a hello to you all – it’s been a while!

Secondly – re: my last post, I read both of Roddy Doyle’s Paula Spencer books and they were really good – you should read them. Not really my best review but that’s what I’ve got on those books.

So then The Beatles! What you have to know about this book review before I start on it is that I love The Beatles and have done so since a very early age. The first Beatles album that I bought was The Red Album which I got on tape from Woolworths in Whitby and which I loved and played and played over and over to the extent where even today when I listen to Beatles albums I still expect certain songs to follow as per their Red Album sequencing as opposed to the tracklisting of say, Rubber Soul or Revolver. I’d listen to the Red Album at home on my parents’ mother of a stereo or in the car on a radio cassette player – via an ear piece. NB: not a walkman, not a ghetto blaster but a battery powered cassette deck and not headphones, no not even ones with orange foam on them – it was a single ear piece which inevitably got covered in various bits of ear wax and dried skin…

Anyway, I love The Beatles and one of my friends in the world hates them. We’ve been friends for nearly 30 years and I can’t believe that I’ve been friends with some so, so different to me but I genuinely love the guy and this review is dedicated to him.

I have read a lot of books about The Beatles over the years – lots of them! Some have been good, some not so good and when I read an interview with Rob Sheffield about his new book  “Dreaming the Beatles: The Love Story of One Band and the Whole World” – I was persuaded to put down a history of Evangelical Christianity in the United States that I’d recently started and pick the book about the Beatles up instead and I didn’t regret it one bit.

It’s not your typical Beatles book – it doesn’t start at a fete in 1957 and end with the release of Paul McCartney’s first solo album though both things are mentioned. What this book is, is a series of essays explaining what the Beatles means to various generations and how the relationship has developed in the years since they spilt up in 1970.

The dark days of the 1970s and crap Beatles compilations are detailed and it’s amazing to remember/discover that there were times when the Beatles’ stock was low and various albums were released through budget label ‘Music for Pleasure’ – compare that with today’s meticulous management of the band’s back catalogue. People never stopped listening to The Beatles but neither were they listened to or bought in quite they way that they are today. If you remember watch The Beatles Anthology then you might need reminding that one of the main reasons it came about was that George Harrison was a little bit tight for cash at the time and as Sheffield points out he didn’t half look uncomfortable when interviewed with Paul McCartney.

If you want a Beatles book with newly uncovered Beatles stories or salacious gossip then this isn’t the book you need, it’s book written by a man who loves the band, has done so for decades and will carry on doing so until the day he days. You’ll want to track down the White Album demos recorded at George’s house – do it, they are great. You’ll yearn for the Let it Be film to be re-released but best of all you’ll ask yourself all over again or you a John, Paul, George or Ringo person?*

It’s a book written from an American perspective which leads to Sheffield stating things such as Paul McCartney only becoming known as Macca in the 90’s which will be news to readers of the very British pop music magazine in which he was known as Paul ‘Fab Macca Wacky Thumbs Aloft’ McCartney from the 80’s – but any quibbles I have are minor.

I enjoyed this book a lot and polished it off in three settings in less than a day, it’s a book you can disagree with – for the love of God, My Love is a classic of McCartney’s oeuvre – a book that gets you listening to tunes that either you’ve written off or simply haven’t listened to in years and it a book that reminds you why The Beatles matter to so many people and will continue to do so.

Also, go and listen to The Rutles.

* I’m not going to answer that here but Blackbird is my favourite Beatles song and my friend mentioned above recently shared with me a recording of his elder daughter singing a cover of it – it is stunning.






Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s